You count the stacks at the end of the night and there are 200 chips fewer than went out. Or 200 more. Everyone looks at everyone else.
It happens in almost every long-running home game played with real chips. Here's how to find the mistake, and what to do if you can't.
Why it happens
Almost always one of these:
- A buy-in or rebuy wasn't written down
- A player took a few chips home in a pocket
- Two players swapped chips and nobody noted it
- A stack was miscounted, usually a big one with a lot of small chips
- Someone counted a chip at the wrong value
Check in this order
Count the chips again. Have the player who owns each stack count it in front of one other person. Most gaps close here.
Compare it with the buy-in record. The chips handed out, rebuys included, should equal every chip on the table. If you handed out 6,000 and there are 5,800 on the table, 200 are missing. If there are 6,200, a rebuy wasn't written down or a chip was counted at the wrong value.
Ask the room. "Did anyone rebuy and forget to say?" solves more of these than any amount of counting.
When you can't find it
Sometimes it's a handful of chips and nobody will ever know why. Agree a rule before it happens:
- The winners absorb it, in proportion. If the count is 200 short and Dana won 2,000 and Lee won 200, Dana's result drops by about 180 and Lee's by about 20.
- Split it evenly. Simple, but it takes chips off players who already lost.
- Ignore small gaps. For a few chips in a long night, nobody minds.
Our view: winners absorb it in proportion. It keeps the order of the table the same, and nobody who finished down ends up further down for a mistake they didn't make.
If there are too many chips
The same options work in reverse. Extra chips nearly always mean a rebuy is missing from the record, so check that first.
Stop it happening again
- Keep one record of buy-ins and rebuys, and update it the moment chips change hands
- Put the chip values on a card on the table
- Count big stacks in front of a second person
- Agree the rule for gaps in advance (see house rules worth agreeing on)
Our free poker chip calculator tells you straight away if the chips at the end don't match the chips in, and by how much. And when you play on Bink, the count can't drift: every chip is tracked, and the ledger always adds up.